- By Romila Thapar

Early India: From the Origins to Ad 1300

  • Title: Early India: From the Origins to Ad 1300
  • Author: Romila Thapar
  • ISBN: 9780520931237
  • Page: 423
  • Format: ebook
  • Early India From the Origins to Ad Early India represents a complete rewriting by Romila Thapar of her classic work A History of India the first volume in the Penguin History of India series thirty five years after it was first publ

    Early India represents a complete rewriting by Romila Thapar of her classic work, A History of India the first volume in the Penguin History of India series , thirty five years after it was first published Thapar has incorporated the vast changes in scholarly understanding and interpretation of Indian history that have occurred during her lifetime to revise the boo Early India represents a complete rewriting by Romila Thapar of her classic work, A History of India the first volume in the Penguin History of India series , thirty five years after it was first published Thapar has incorporated the vast changes in scholarly understanding and interpretation of Indian history that have occurred during her lifetime to revise the book for a new generation of readers This new work brings to life thousands of years of history, tracing India s evolution before contact with modern Europe was established its prehistoric beginnings the great cities of the Indus civilization the emergence of mighty dynasties such as the Mauryas, Guptas, and Cholas the teachings of the Buddha the creation of heroic epics such as the Mahabharata and the Ramayana and the creation of regional cultures Thapar introduces figures from the remarkable visionary ruler Ashoka to other less exemplary figures In exploring subjects as diverse as marriage, class, art, erotica, and astronomy, Thapar provides an incomparably vivid and nuanced picture of India Above all, she shows the rich mosaic of diverse kingdoms, landscapes, languages, and beliefs.

    1 thought on “Early India: From the Origins to Ad 1300

    1. I enjoy reading history, and am just becoming interested in the history of India and central Asia. I figured a Penguin book on the topic would be just what I needed. That was not the case. I was looking for a book which told me stories about Indian history, instead I got a soulless Marxist manifesto. This year I've read two great history books - "The Fall of the Roman Empire" by Peter Heather, and "Consuming Passions" by Judith Flanders. Both were great books which entertained me and left me wit [...]

    2. To describe Romila Thapar, I would like to employ (with slight variation) an unknown quote by a famous journalist for Indira Gandhi, "She is the only MAN among the Indian intellectuals" Early India is one of the best books I have read this year. Romila Thapar is among handful of Indian intellectuals who have the courage to stand up against the cultural rape of our history. She is not famous among Hindutava circle because her work stands between their ambition to distort the past and depress the [...]

    3. This is an erudite and impressive work. A social, economic, cultural and religious history of India from the origins to 1300 CE. Romila Thapar is a very well-known historian in India and her texts are widely used in universities here. She is also infamous in the Hindutva circles because of her Marxist credentials, but that’s only a political opposition rather than any academic criticism. She gives only a brief overview of pre-history and starts with the first urbanisation in the Indus valley c [...]

    4. Penguin claims this book "brings Indian History to life". I would posit that this book and its author kill Indian history, dismember the corpse, burn the remains and plod mechanically through the ashes.Now that I've vent my spleen, so to speak, let's vent a little more. :)This isn't a book meant for the lay reader or the history buff. If anyone, it is suited for First Year students of BA (History). You lucky guys can just copy-paste paragraphs from the book right into your answer sheets. :DTo ca [...]

    5. This one took me much longer than I expected, but there is a lot of dense information packed into this small volume. I won't pretend I memorized everything in the book, since it packs a period of over 2000 years into less than 400 pages. That said, it entertained me for the most part, and informed me a great deal about Indian societies of the past. My one minor beef is Ms. Thapar's claim that Sufism came from Shi'i Islam against Sunni orthodoxy. Say what? Unlike her detractors, however, I can fo [...]

    6. The first half of the book is quite interesting where Thapar talks about historiography and how biases and agendas of diverse groups affect their periodization and narrative of history, and the book begins quite promisingly with a the description of the social milieu. However, in the later chapters, especially after the Gupta empire or so the book becomes too unfocussed and difficult to follow when it ends up as a listing of too many facts without any sort of clear thread of events. Sure, histor [...]

    7. dedication:For Sergei: in memoriam and remembering Kaushalya and Daya Ram and our many years together.Opening: The modern writing of Indian history began with colonial perceptions of the Indian past that were to be seminal to its subsequent interpretations. It took shape with the beginnings of colonial rule in various parts of the subcontinent from the eighteenth century onwards.To check up:twelfth-century history of Kashmir, the Rajatarangini, written by Kalhana.Max WeberNot an engaging text ye [...]

    8. This book may have all the information one might require for a general survey of India before the coming of the Mughals and the Portuguese, but the style is listless and documentary. Better, I suppose, than sensationalistic, but it was still difficult for me to shoulder on through it. Part of the problem I admit was my own lack of knowledge about Indian geography and political divisions. The author frequently referred to geographic areas of India which I couldn't place in my head (the maps were [...]

    9. Review originally posted in Abby's Shelf: wp/p7MnAP-cMHistory of Early India: From the origins to AD 1300 by Romila Thapar is probably the most authoritative book I have read on this topic. But even when I say this do keep in mind to never mistake this book as a light read, this is a very intense information packed book which may even break the most avid fan of History. I actually slept off few nights reading this book. Now while reviewing this book I faced a challenge that forced me to take a d [...]

    10. Well its Romila Thaper informative and based on research but definitely it is not a tale. Not inspiring and difficult to complete

    11. As insightful as Ms. Romila Thapar gets, gives a holistic view on the evolution of the Ancient Indian society along with factors which primarily impacted political formation of kingdoms. Must read for a history enthusiast even if he/she's gone through the NCERT book written by Ms. Romila Thapar.

    12. A comprehensive but very concise review of 3000 years of Indian history (up to 1300 AD). In a little over 300 pages, Prof. Thapar provides a tour of the arrival of the Aryans in India, Alexander's raid, the Mauryan empire and the interregnum that followed its collapse, the classical age of the Guptas, the southern Indian empires, the early Sultanate period, up to the demise of Vijayanagar. The story ends with the Mughals entering India from the north, even as European explorers find their way to [...]

    13. I wanted to flesh out my understanding of early Indian history, especially in the realms of politics, economics, art, and regional differences. I also wanted an accessible "master narrative" from a premier social historian. The narrative is there from time to time, but this book is mostly details. On the plus side, names and dates of dynasties and wars, descriptions of terms of art found in each period's texts, and a brief fleshing out of technological and religious advances. On the minus, somet [...]

    14. I would never recommend this book or any book written by Romila Thapar to any one (except you are preparing for UPSC exams). Utterly disgusted by this leftist history telling, felt as if Indian history narrated by some India hater. Be it Ram Guha or Romila Thapar they mastered the art of demeaning India's past, fabricating theories and applying western sense of righteousness in their history telling. For a 555 page History book, evidences/facts are seldom referred, on the contrary the entire boo [...]

    15. First with due respect to the author, she has provided a detailed history of India, not a simple task and i greatly acknowledge her immense wisdom. As a south indian, i found the chapters on Chola dynasty to be wanting ( more could have been written). Also, i felt the author belittles hindu mythology and puranas. In my Humble Opinion, Overall, it is a history of India of a left leaning author.

    16. This caught my eye because it carried a gushing recommendation on the back from Eric Hobsbawm, a historian not usually given to such feelings. But here the recommendation was well earned; here is an erudite, well balanced and thorough history of India free of nationalist bias which isn't easy to do, especially considering the current political climate in the country.

    17. Her presentation of history is accurate and detailed. She puts forth the reason for what happened and deduces on the effect of all parameters that make history. Its not just a compendium of facts but helps one think and make one's own deductions of those facts. Good Read

    18. A very concise and crisp description of ancient and early medieval India. Romila Thapar is a very talented writer and historian who manages to hook you from the very first line. Besides the factual details, there is also an active engagement with primary sources through which the author offers her viewpoints and conclusions with clarity and reason. She also artfully critiques the political manipulation of certain historical narratives from this period and instead posits for a more a nuanced and [...]

    19. OOOUUUUUU YAAASSSSSS THIS BOOOKKK HAS THE WHOLE HISTORY OF INDIA Where it was located?How many counties colonised it?and etcThis book is LIT if you are an indian or anyone and wish to know more about THE HISTORY ABOUT INDIA BUY THIS BOOK OR BORROW IT

    20. To explain the history of such a vast and diverse subcontinent over a large period of 3,000 years, with only the significant details is not mean fete. Yet, Romila Thapar has done a marvelous job. Without digressing to unnecessary details and smoothly weaving a story across the cultural and economic development of the Indian subcontinent, the book is true to its name.Firstly, the things I did not like about the book. There is an uncontrolled bashing of the brahmin cult throughout the book. Invari [...]

    21. When I asked a friend from India for a good overview of Indian history, she recommended this one. A few years later I have finished it. It's long, academic, and historical. But it is readable. I really appreciated the thoughtful structuring: various historical periods are each examined from the perspective of economics, cultural happenings, and society structure and interaction. While different things are known about different periods, it was nice to know that Ms. Thapar would look at each of th [...]

    22. My spouse bought this book while in India, and in the back, we can read "for sale in the Indian Subcontinent and Singapore only". Maybe then this is why this book feels so "foreign" - it is filled with Indian words and concepts that are so different from ours that I failed to grasp the relevance of several paragraphs. Moreover, the author, a leading authority in Indian history, puts out several suggestions for additional research, as if she expected this book to be read mainly by her university [...]

    23. She had written a somewhat leftist (though not strictly Marxist) version of ancient and early medivial Indian History. The review of literary evidence is at times biased. The treatment of Archealogical evidences are not as good as done by Upinder Singh. The language is very complicated and flowery. So much so that in almost every paragraph I had to look for a dictionary. The wotk however is well researched and you feel like sitting in a time machine. She had covered the evolution of religion rea [...]

    24. An in-depth account of the period from pre-history till about 1200AD. A book with more insights than facts. A lot more focus on social conditions than about kings and the wars they waged. Her bias against Vedic Brahmanism is obvious and you have to apply that filter. I like the fact that she covers the sources (archeological, literary) of how we know what we know about history. Half-way done and am at the turn of the 1st millennium AD. Very minimal coverage of South Indian history so far.

    25. It's more of a social history, concentrating in movements of groups of people say into South India, or how guilds might have conducted trade in the "middle ages"; rather than on the exploits of rulers and the battles they fought. The book was a real eye opener for me. Romila Thapar is the most balanced and respected historian in the country presently and has no leanings (Marxist or Communalist).

    26. Romila Thapar is an excellent writer and almost certainly a fine scholar. And there is plenty of interesting subject matter in this book. But Thapar's assignment here was almost impossible: There is so much information here in such a short book--names, concepts, kingdoms, epochs often fly by with blinding speed--that too many passages are almost indigestible.

    27. A serious work of History.A must read for everyone who didn't take history seriously in their schooldays(like me :)).Its not embellished with any kind of flowery plots/language and presents the available facts and the possible conclusions.The chapters on formation of Jatis and Indo-Greek Rule in Northwest are the best.

    28. Romila Thapar is big name in history and she proved she is . Her approach to tell the whole history is best thing . This book is not a book of kings ,dates and wars but covers whole area of religion,cultures , cast , trade and shifts in these areas . The narrative is bit boring and it takes more time than you expect but it's different from others .

    29. This was a refreshing read Ms Thapar's work stands for her status in academic world. This work is definitely a very well researched book and it takes you onto a vivid journey of India's historical past. Her writing is subtle,sober and analytic in nature One of my favourite chapters was on feudalism which was brilliantly written and explained. I would recommend this to all.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *